Vero Beach 19th Team

In September of 2013, Supreme Title opened our 3rd title agency in downtown Vero Beach, Florida. This was the first Supreme Title office to open in Indian River County. A centrally-located office nestled in downtown Vero Beach, our expert team of title agents and staff are ready to help you with your real estate closing process. We make it easy to work with your favorite title agent from any of our five branches, and you can close in the most convenient location for your needs.

Supreme Title, including any new locations, always remains steadfast to our three principals: Accountability, Affordability, and Accessibility.

Success Stories

“I represented the buyer and Sherri did an amazing job. ALWAYS communicating with us and helped us reach a successful closing, highly recommend!”
“Althea was delightful, professional and completely prepared to take care of the closing. She answered our questions quickly and accurately.”
“Closing on our new home was simple and without any hassles. Thank you to Sherri and Jill for the warm, professional support!”
Google Rating
5.0
Carol McAdams

Carol McAdams

Manager | Indian River

Carol has over 15 years of experience in the title industry. She began by working for a national title company; the experience allowed her to work with customers at a local, regional and national level. Carol was recognized as the top sales producer within her division for 3 consecutive years. A great part of her success came from her continual commitment to expand her abilities and the company’s capabilities to meet and exceed their customers’ definition of great customer service. With this background, Carol has a clear understanding that not everyone fits into one mold. Being fluent in Spanish also helps Carol to meet the needs of Spanish-speaking customers.


Email: Carol@supremetitlellc.com

Don McAdams

Don McAdams

Office Manager | Indian River

Don is originally from Milwaukee and is relatively new to the title industry. He brings his natural people skills, and commitment to providing bar none the best customer service in the industry. On Don’s off time he loves spending time fixing cars, hanging with his beautiful wife Carol and their 3 adorable boys.


Email: Don@supremetitlellc.com

Althea James

Althea James

Title Agent | Indian River

Althea James was born and raised in New York but moved to Florida in 1998. Althea loves “all things real estate” and is the complete trifecta: she has worked in the real estate, mortgage and title industry since her move to Florida. She currently holds a Florida license in real estate; and more recently, as a title agent. Althea loves assisting her clients through the home buying/selling process – and she is especially fond of first-time homeowners. Althea is a self-proclaimed fashionista especially for shoes, but her favorite hobby is decorating (or redecorating) her home and shopping for vintage home décor. She has 2 wonderful kids; her son Mekhi is 23 and her daughter Shayla is 20.


Email: althea@supremetitlellc.com

Sherri Reynolds

Sherri Reynolds

Closer | Indian River

Sherri was born and raised in Northern California. She moved to Vero Beach in support of her husband’s career with no idea what the future would hold for her. She started her career as an admin for a local real estate firm, then took a job with Supreme Title. Somewhere along the way she also obtained a Florida Real Estate License and even dabbled in property management. She has been with the Supreme Title family for many years now and wouldn’t have it any other way! She has worked her way from processor to closer and continues to learn something new every day. She believes that if you finish a day without new knowledge, it’s because you didn’t try hard enough. In her free time, she enjoys spending time in her ever-growing garden and dining out.


Email: Sherri@supremetitlellc.com

Kim Ludwig

Kim Ludwig

Processor | Indian River

Kimberly Ludwig moved to Florida in 1980 and fell totally in love! Kim’s career background is in the legal field. She transitioned to the real estate industry in 2017 when she started working for a real estate attorney and her love for the title industry grew from there. She strives to make clients feel at ease throughout the entire process. Kim spends her free time with friends and family boating, eating out, watching movies, and going to the beach. She has two wonderful sons; Brett who is 28 and is expecting his first child; Austin who is 26 and is a Marine.


Email: kim@supremetitlellc.com

Jill Stiriz

Jill Stiriz

Processor | Indian River

Jill’s career in Real Estate began over 25 years ago in loan origination, processing, and funding. She moved to Vero Beach in 1999 and started working within our local community, meeting with homeowners and home buyers to build strong professional relationships. She has a great knowledge of the mortgage process and is thrilled to be able to carry that to the title side of the industry. Jill is a wife, mother, and grandmother – she especially loves to spend time with her 3 local grandchildren. She is also owned by 2 Sheltand Sheepdogs that run the house!


Email: jill@supremetitlellc.com